Appskosam Brilliant narration about the animal instinctive males. The only thing with killing insects... is we do it a lot. I won't mention what I use to do when I was growing up in Jamaica...to lizards.... And I didn't even say what I done...I was only little and living at one with nature guys....lmao. A product called Orange Guard is a nontoxic organic ant repellent that is harmless to humans and other animals and will drive ants away from areas where they are not wanted. That's wickedly cruel Elric and you know it!!! Often our laws don't match up with what is morally right and wrong. Couldn't one argue that by removing the limbs rendering the ant unable to move is a form of tortue regardless of pain? Imagine, i mean really imagine in your mind, how it would feel to burn to death in a matter of minutes from the suns rays, how does it feel? I surely would NOT teach my kids to do that! Indianapolis based Hard Rock/Metal band It suggests a level of thought out planning while stepping on an ant is usually done on a whim. More information will be released as the game nears a release date so keep an eye out. Fire ants get their name due to the burning sensation you feel once you are bitten. 42% Upvoted. It's cruel Elric and I remember my Brother forever getting told of by Mum for doing that back in the 60's !! Out of curiosity, I pulled a leg off, wondering if it was actually possible for humans to torture insects by removing theirs legs. The ant is viewed as a notorious pest, causing billions of dollars in damages annually and impacting wildlife. Though, after I had pulled off several of it's legs, it did seem to move faster. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the askphilosophy community. It just seems inevitable I will have a lot of guilt on my hands. I think it's wrong to harm humans, but I do not think it is wrong to harm animals. Not only is it not a good thing to do to the ants....... the kids could start a wildfire, such as the ones in California. If they can then it opens up a lot of utilitarian questions about whether or not we should shift our efforts to make bugs happier since there are so many of them. Is following a lot of insta accounts indicative of someone who doesn’t have a life, prob poor diet, lack of exercise no job etc . For those of you that say torturing an ant is wrong and I did something awful. The same would be true if were in a vegetative state. Problem is there is a lot of different arguments about what a person is and what a person isn't. save. If the ant was in pain, then yes, what you did was wrong. If the ant wasn't in pain, by definition you weren't torturing it. They have starter tunnels and everything the book said to do but still no activity. but not for torturing insects? No but taking the tops of tar bubbles (you know when it gets hot in summer and the tarmac bubbles) putting the ant in then putting the top back on that's cruel! The sentience or sapience of a thing isn't always a necessary condition for its consideration, morally or legally. If you came up to me and said "you can't enslave black people! Consider the age of your children and if they will be able to properly care for the ant farm. Well, I pulled it off. 42 comments. Its a natural way of life. If torturing ants is as bad as dogs, why isn't bug fighting illegal. I imagine that torturing ants would probably not be considered an especially virtuous act by anyone, and would likely not be considered a pathway to a life worth living. Why is it that we arrest people for torturuing dogs and etc. He isn’t burning them! For example, there were once two men who led a boy scout troop into the desert, during which the men kicked over one of some unique and ancient weathered rock formations called 'goblins'. A man who creates and sells intricate casts of ant colonies by filling the subterranean mini caverns with molten aluminium has responded to heavy criticism. Puanlamalar ve Yorumlar. We kill bugs by stepping on them without knowing. Before you call me a psychopath and say I need counselling... please know that I am not an especially cruel person. Seriously, animal abuse is in NO WAY acceptable. See http://reducing-suffering.org/do-bugs-feel-pain/. In Asia they actually have "bug fights". http://reducing-suffering.org/do-bugs-feel-pain/. However, when applied directly to ants, the active ingredient d-Limonene (orange peel extract) destroys the waxy coating of the insects’ respiratory systems, causing the ants to suffocate, so please do not spray ants with the repellent. You can sign in to vote the answer. how many of u think its bad or funny U.S. has long favored cars. Torture is wrong because its vicious and cruel, and a good person would not do it. However, a common misconception is that what causes the distressing burning sensation is a fire ant's bite, when it's actually their sting. That's wrong!" After pulling the limbs off the ant, there still was no indication that it was in pain. However, bringing an ant farm into your home is not without risks. Kant himself argued that kindness towards animals is only an imperfect duty, and that we should be kind to them because otherwise we lose our tenderness, the cultivation of which is an imperfect duty we have towards ourselves. We'd place pebbles up against a kerb, then using old lollipop sticks we'd build bridges, fill it with water and see if the ants could get across! Have you ever wondered why our universe is so freaking big? I don't like the little buggers but I couldn't hurt even them. that's what a magnifying glass is for......is it not????????? If you knew me, I am sure you would think I am normal. - posted in General Ant Keeping: Hiya, My name is Olga and for a few years I am interested in ants but I have never had a colony but only a few L.niger workers due to a fright of having too many ants that I cant stop breeding. It wasn't "fun"... - Other Question In that instance, the worm squirms, not sure if out of pain or some other reason. For those of you that say torturing an ant is wrong and I did something awful. I'm a "Mrs Do-as-you-would-be -done-by" , Elric . 761 likes. More recently, Korsgaard has argued that animal should be considered to have value in kantian ethics, and she thinks that she can derive the duties we have towards animals from Kant's formulation of the categorical imperative, but I don't remember how her argument goes specifically, only that I was not conviced by it when I read her relevant paper. For millions of years, dinosaurs did the same things to ants. 3 years ago. Ants like to feed off Honeydew which is secreted by Aphids (sap-sucking insects) as they feed on plant sap. /r/askphilosophy aims to provide serious, well-researched answers to philosophical questions. It just started to walk away in the same manner it was walking before I had even disturbed it. Both might still cause pain -- if not immediately then perhaps after the "heat of the moment" has passed? If I were to cut away parts of a person who was completely paralyzed from the neck down, it would still be a cruel and vicious act. The Smell of Burning Ants explores the socialisation of boys, showing how the quotidian rituals of violence that characterise growing up male lead to repressed fear and anger, which can only be expressed in further violence. I think burning ants is sick and I would stop any child I would find doing such a thing, explaining to them that ants are living beings that can feel pain. Lol...What's everyone up in arms about? If it's not in pain, why is torturing an ant so terrible? I think the bigger question is whether or not insects and other bugs are sentient. Or how much it'll cost for a cleanup of the system.???? If it wasn't, then it may still have been wrong to kill the ant, but maybe not to torture it, if there's something wrong with painless killing. me and my friends think burning ants with a magnafying glass is hillarios but some old lady in the park got mad at me and said it was mean =O. Also, stepping on an ant is a quick death for the insect, while burning it with a magnifying glass is much more slow and painful. We'd place pebbles up against a kerb, then using old lollipop sticks we'd build bridges, fill it with water and see if the ants … And if a cop sees someone burning an ant why don't they get in trouble? You need to be careful to divorce "no indication that it was in pain" from "it was not in pain." So, I picked it up to move it off and realized that I could actually hold it by one of it's limbs/legs. 35 likes. best. To keep a constant supply of Honeydew, ants protect aphids from predators like Ladybirds and tend to their ongoing needs. I remember as a kid, cutting a worm to see it grow back istelf in two pieces. Best Answer. hide. Sort by . If torturing ants is as bad as dogs, why isn't bug fighting illegal. It's hard to say without more info. Alternatively maybe pleasure and pain are separate from sentience, but similar thinking applies. Join Yahoo Answers and get 100 points today. If the ant was in pain, then yes, what you did was wrong. Ant farms are extremely safe if properly maintained, but this can be difficult if you’re buying an ant farm for small children. Still curious, I proceeded to pull off each of it's limbs or legs until it was almost unable to walk. February 06, 2018 02:06. They were charged criminally IIRC, but even if they weren't, the American people seem to agree that the rock formations are deserving of consideration such that we shouldn't damage or destroy them. There may be times when we are unable to avoid causing harm, or when causing harm is a good thing, but IMO torture goes far beyond these sort of marginal cases. It was walking across the blanket I was sitting on. If it wasn't, then it may still have been wrong to kill the ant. In either case I think the answer is no but I'm not a neuroscientist so I don't know. The ants thrive in urban areas, so their presence may deter outdoor activities. You can make an argument that ants lack the qualities of personhood and therefore determining the morality of whether it is right or wrong to torture them is insignificant. Children have to learn this, which is why, if you find a child < 5ys old hurting an animal, you need to teach them why this is not ok. My question is if it's really wrong to do this to inscects... as far as my observations go... the insect seemed unable to feel the pain. We usually kill bugs in our house, bugs that fly on our shoulders we swat and kill accidententally or on prupose, I garden and use pesticides to get rid of pests. Someone who does this or who pulls legs off of a creature may require a watchful … but not for torturing insects? Fire ants bite to latch on, then use their stinger to create a painful, itchy bump. Because it kept running away rather than flailing around? Get your answers by asking now. Very likely it would go against the virtue of kindness, but I don't know of any authors who have written about animal ethics from a stand point of virtue. So to provide an answer to your question we would have to know wether or not ants can feel pleasure or pain. Is it okay to keep a few workers together without a queen, or is it too cruel? This is due to the high concentration of toxins in fire ant venom. just focus magnifying glass on ant but the sunlight should fall on the magnifying glass. Sıralama: Lu Who's rating of the film The Smell of Burning Ants. Burning an ant with a magnifying glass is a bit different than stepping on an ant though. If indeed ants feel pain, our laws fail to match up with what is morally right and wrong. and I replied "oh yeah? To the “but that’s cruel” comments: What are you talking about. Well, how come we arrest people for enslaving white people, but not for enslaving black people?" Poll: What’s the closest you’ve been to a Dangerous Animal? It seems that worms possess a much greater capacity for pain. Using images drawn from a dizzying array of black-and-white films from the past, this visual essay follows the story of a single boy to communicate its mythic message. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Are there any philosophers that argue that the pain of animals is not worthy of moral consideration? Every time I did so it didn't really show any signs of being in pain. I take it you would not be very convinced with my reply. … This thread is archived. Cops open fire during standoff with swimming suspect, Baylor advances to NCAA tournament championship, Ken Burns: People making lots of money off ‘big lie’, Norton landed breakout role after DiCaprio passed, Country star feels major pressure to lose weight. This is a question for the relevant experts. 1 0; Appskosam's rating of the film The Smell of Burning Ants . I figure if they're sentient then they can feel pleasure and pain and if they're not then they can't. And if a cop sees someone burning an ant why don't they get in trouble? Then, I squished it's back-end. They're transparent? Did you ever burn ants with a magnifying glass when you … He just shined a light at them. I did let it struggle for a little though. I also have an antworks ant farm and my colony in there still hasn't dug after a week. When I was a kid we used to build ant assault courses. If they grow older and keep hurting animals, they and/or their parents need mental health … report. Lu Who 4.5 // so in love this was made in 1994. At this point it was unable to move. Can Biden change that? For a slower-moving worm, wiggling about might be the best way to escape from a predator, while for an ant, perhaps running away is best. No but taking the tops of tar bubbles (you know when it gets hot in summer and the tarmac bubbles) putting the ant in then putting the top back on that's cruel! lol. It isn't cruel to keep ants in ant farms... but it might be in that specific ant farm. It reacts a lot more than the ant. Dog fights but with insects. We use cookies on our websites for a number of purposes, including analytics and performance, functionality and advertising. Finally, what virtue ethics have to say on the matter is, as it often is with this kind of ethics, a bit unclear. Nests can be built under structures such as pavements and foundations, which may cause structural problems, or cause them to collapse. The thermal pads are being destroyed by these ants. Something similar is going on here. Not only can they damage or destroy structures, but red imported fire ants also can … The most convincing theories of animal ethics I know of are consequentialist. Ants - the cruel world is a new RTS (real time strategy) game. The ants are hiding under the keyboard.Can anyone link a tutorial on how to remove the keyboard from the system.I'm finding black adhesive attached below the motherboard which is strong, the ants are below that layer. Sickly black bears acting friendlier around humans, Possible virus exposure at NCAA tourney investigated, NCAA tourney coach won't apologize for profane talk, DMX off life support, but 'not out of the woods' yet, Teacher goes on racist Zoom rant, parent alleges. Maybe someone else can jump in on this one. If they don't they are only important in as far as your actions towards ants have an effect on valid targets of ethical considerations (like, for example, yourself, if it turns out that torturing ants is harmful to your own mental health). Your belief that the ant wasn't in pain or distress gave you cause to harm it, but even if we grant that you caused it no pain or distress we can still recognize that there was harm done. For instance, in the United States it used to be legal to enslave black people, but not white people. Is it cruel? No different to stepping on them and it keeps them away for the house anyway! Anyways, today I was sitting in my backyard and saw an ant. From the perspective of deontological theories, things look a little different. The Smell of Burning Ants. That's cruel and if I saw kids going that, they would have ME to answer to and Gawd help 'em. Still have questions? I did killed dozens of ants as a kid, with all sorts of things, magnifying glass included; It didn't turn me into a psychopath. Peter Singer is an example of a philosopher who defends this kind of theory of animal ethics. What made you think the ant wasn't in pain? You're not exactly in a position to tell us whether the ants were in pain because you don't know anything about ants. share. 2005-04-04T14:22. The ants would get singed, or start to feel the heat, and start running, and these two knuckleheads thought it was hilarious. I hope you guys enjoy this we got request to do it and so we did it here you guys go! Adam And The Ants never sang about a "magnifying Glass", they just preached about "Don't step on an ant"!!!!!!!!!! If your child knocks the farm over, or wants to take the ants out to get a better look, you may end up with an ant infestation. How do you think about the answers? Press J to jump to the feed. Burning Giant, Indianapolis, Indiana. When I was a kid we used to build ant assault courses. Ants - the cruel world. Why is it that we arrest people for torturuing dogs and etc. Then, it started to die and I eventually just crushed it's head. Ant farms were once labeled as toys and hardly reflected an ant's natural environment, which begs the question: are they cruel? Ants, as individuals, do not seem like very complicated animals to me (I’m sure E. O. Wilson would correct me), but every time I smush one I am aware I am extinguishing for all eternity one being’s single chance to be alive. xapim ACE Posts: 6,177 Pathfinder. Then, it started to walk away like nothing had happened. So many guys at my job wanna put his penis on me. level 1. political phil. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Burning an Ant Hill with Gasoline and Fire - Duration: 4:09. sensation13579 82,460 views This protection often causes an increase in aphid activity all over your garden. 0. We all kill ants every time we walk outdoors...and indoors. If they do, they should be valid targets of ethical considerations. (We often think there is something wrong with painless killing when it comes to human beings, so maybe it is wrong to painlessly kill other animals, too.). They usually take the position that, among other things, possessing the ability to experience pleasure and pain makes you a valid target for ethical considerations. … It didn't even appear to run away in a traumatized way. Puanlamalar ve Yorumlar.

Ge Matte Black Vs Black Slate, Esb Meaning Army, Samsung Bespoke 4-door Flex Refrigerator Price, Replace Fj Cruiser Engine, Fan En Français, Dylon Cold Water Dye Instructions, Ebay Frigidaire Refrigerator Parts, What To Do With Deer Hide, Mark Twain Writings,